Hearing Stream 6

Hearing Stream 6 took place on 15 and 17 November 2022 in the Council Chambers, 28-32 Ruataniwha Street, Waipawa. 

This Hearing Stream was for: Mapping and Miscellaneous.   This covers Rezoning Requests, ECO-SCHED5 and Mapping of Significant Natural Areas, General Mapping, Part 1 Introduction and General Provisions, and Miscellaneous /Other Matters.

Key Dates

Key dates for Hearing Stream 6 as per the Hearing Schedule are:

• 7 October - Submitter Notification
• 14 October - s42A Officers' reports published
• 20 October - Submitters wishing to be heard need to advise the Administrator before 1pm on this date at districtplan@chbdc.govt.nz
• 31 October - Submitters wishing to submit expert evidence must do so before 1pm on this date
• 10 November - Submitters wishing to submit a legal submission must do so before 1pm this date
• 15 November - Hearing Stream 6: Miscellaneous, Introduction and Rezoning, will commence in the Council Chambers,
  28-32 Ruataniwha Street, Waipawa

Key Documents

Hearing Notice for Hearing Stream 6 - Mapping and Miscellaneous 

List of submitters and provisions commented on to be heard in Hearing Stream 6

Errata Memo - Amendment to Key Dates Submitter Notice Hearing Stream 6 - Mapping and Miscellaneous (12 October 2022)

Hearing Stream 6 Schedule

AGENDA - Hearing Stream 6 Tuesday 15 November 2022

AGENDA - Hearing Stream 6 Thursday 17 November 2022

s42A Reports

Section 42A - SNA Mapping Natural Environment 

Section 42A - Mapping and Rezoning Requests (Volume 1)

Section 42A - Mapping and Rezoning Requests (Volume 2)

Section 42A - Miscellaneous

Submitter Evidence/Statements

Submitter Statement - Ministry of Education  [S73] HS6 

Submitter Statement - Horticulture New Zealand (Jordyn Landers) [S81, FS17] HS6

Submitter Statement - Transpower New Zealand Limited (Trudi Burney) [S79, FS18] HS6

Submitter Statement - Tylee Land Co [S7] HS6

Submitter Statement - House Movers Section of New Zealand Heavy Haulage Association Inc (Jonathan Bhana-Thomson) [S106] HS6

Submitter Statement - House Movers Section of New Zealand Heavy Haulage Association Inc (Elwyn Fryer) [S106] HS6

Submitter Statement - The Surveying Company Ltd (Nick Wakefield) [S50] HS6

Submitter Evidence (Joint) - Pairatahi Holdings Limited [S92], Paul Robottom [S68] and the C&H Hardy Family Trust and Lime Terrace Farm [S52] HS6

Submitter Evidence - James Bridge (Steve Goodman) [S105, FS4] - HS6 

Submitter Evidence - James Bridge (Angela McFlynn) [S105, FS4] - HS6 

Submitter Evidence - Livingston Properties Limited (Bill Livingston) [S127,FS27] HS6

Submitter Evidence - Livingston Properties Limited (Phil McKay, Planning) [S127,FS27] HS6

Submitter Evidence - Livingston Properties Limited (Andrew Taylor, Appendices A-D) [S127,FS27] HS6

Submitter Evidence - Livingston Properties Limited (Andrew Taylor) [S127,FS27] HS6

Submitter Evidence - Livingston Properties Limited  (Aaron Campion, Traffic) [S127,FS27] HS6

Submitter Evidence - Livingston Properties Limited (Aaron Campion, Traffic, Appendix A) [S127,FS27] HS6

Submitter Evidence - Livingston Properties Limited (Aaron Campion, Traffic, Appendix B) [S127,FS27] HS6

Submitter Evidence - Livingston Properties Limited (Greg Morice) [S127,FS27] HS6

Submitter Evidence - Livingston Properties Limited (Greg Morice, Soils, Appendix 1) [S127,FS27] HS6

Submitter Evidence - Livingston Properties Limited (Greg Morice, Soils, Appendix 2) [S127,FS27] HS6

Submitter Evidence - Livingston Properties Limited (Cam Wylie, Geotech) [S127,FS27] HS6

Submitter Evidence - Livingston Properties Limited (Cam Wylie, Geotech, Appendix A) [S127,FS27] HS6

Submitter Evidence - Livingston Properties Limited (Shannon Bray, Landscape) [S127,FS27] HS6

Submitter Evidence - Livingston Properties Limited (Shannon Bray, Landscape, Appendix A) [S127,FS27] HS6

Submitter Evidence - Livingston Properties Limited (Shannon Bray, Landscape, Appendix B) [S127,FS27] HS6

Submitter Evidence - M & L Lowry [S35] HS6

Submitter Evidence - Jane Davidson [S16] HS6

Submitter Evidence - Silver Fern Farms Limited [S116, FS8] HS6

Submitter Evidence - Heretaunga Tamatea Settlement Trust (Stephen Daysh) [S120, FS13] HS6 

Submitter Statement - Central Hawke's Bay District Council (Nick Aiken) HS6

Submitter Evidence - Central Hawke's Bay District Council (Nick Aiken) HS6

Legal Overview

Central Hawke's Bay District Council's Legal Overview  HS6 

Legal Submissions

Legal Submission - James Bridge (Steve Goodman) [S105, FS4] HS6

Legal Submission - Livingston Properties Limited [S127, FS27] HS6

Submitter Presentations

Submitter Presentation - M & L Lowry (L MacGillivray - Agribusiness Consultant) [S35] HS6

Submitter Presentation (Joint) - Pairatahi Holdings Limited [S92], Paul Robottom [S68] and the C&H Hardy Family Trust and Lime Terrace Farm [S52] (Ellen Robotham - Consultant) HS6

Submitter Speaking Notes - Pairatahi Holdings Limited [S92] HS6

Submitter Speaking Notes - Paul Robottom [S68] HS6

Submitter Speaking Notes - C&H Hardy Family Trust and Lime Terrace Farm [S52] HS6

Submitter Speaking Notes - Kairakau Lands Trust [S84] HS6

Submitter Presentation - Livingston Properties Limited [S127, FS27] (Andrew Taylor) HS6

Submitter Presentation - Livingston Properties Limited [S127, FS27] (Shannon Bray) HS6 

Supplementary Hearing Statements/Evidence

Supplementary Submitter Evidence - M & L Lowry (L MacGillivray - Agribusiness Consultant) [S35] HS6

Supplementary Submitter Statement -  Pairatahi Holdings Limited [S92] HS6

Supplementary Submitter Evidence - Livingston Properties Limited (Provisions to Implement Structure Plan) [S127, FS27] HS6

Supplementary Submitter Evidence - Livingston Properties Limited (Mt Herbert Road Precinct Plan) [S127, FS27] HS6

Council Reply

Council Reply - Hearing Stream 6 SNA Mapping 

Council Reply - Hearing Stream 6 SNA Mapping (updated recommendations in response to site visits) 27 January 2023

Council Reply – Hearing Stream 6 Rezonings & NPS-HPL Alignment (Final) – this is the complete document, incorporating all the appendices

• Appendix 2 – Updated Recommended Amendments to Plan Provisions:
• SUB – Subdivision chapter
• GRZ-APP1 – Waipukurau South Precinct (WSP) Plan
• Appendix 3 – Updated Tables of Recommended Responses to Submissions
• 3a - Rezonings table
• 3b - Rural Environment table (revisited in light of NPS-HPL)
• Appendix 4 – Background Review Documents:
• 4a - Area-based Infrastructure Assessment Report (VCV Consulting, Jun 20)
• 4b - Central Hawke’s Bay Integrated Spatial plan 2020-2050 (adopted Sep 20)
• 4c - Household Growth Response Report (Sage Planning, Nov 20)
• Appendix 5 – Resource Consent RM180160/RM180160A

 Council Reply – Hearing Stream 6 Miscellaneous (Final) – this is the complete document, incorporating all the appendices

• Appendix 2 – Updated Recommended Amendments to Plan Provisions - MISC
• Appendix 3 – Updated Table of Recommended Responses to Submissions - MISC
• Appendix 4 – Copy of NZHHA Building Pre-Inspection Report Template - MISC

Council Legal Reply - Hearing Stream 6 - Rezoning (Asher Davidson) 

Reference Documents

Hastings District Council Standards for Relocated Buildings - Example taken from Chapter 7.2 Residential Environment (Page 41) HS6

Recommendation and Decisions Report on NPS - HPL - Livingston Properties Ltd [S127, FS27](Callum Beattie) HS6

Abraham Holdings Ltd v North Shore City Council EnvC A06907 - Livingston Properties Ltd [S127, FS27] (Martin Williams) HS6

Middle Hill Ltd v Auckland Council 92022) NZEnvC 162 - Livingston Properties Ltd [S127, FS27] (Martin Williams) HS6

National Policy Statement Highly Productive Land (September 2022) - Livingston Properties Ltd 9S127, FS27] (Martin Williams) HS6

Hearings Stream 6, Day 1

Hearings Stream 6, Day 2